That Time I Thought I’d Be a Priest

Grand Canyon, Inner Canyon, 2019
Native Land of the Hopi, Havasupai, Southern Paiute, and Pueblos (source

There was a time in my life when I thought my path was shaping up like the picture above: onward to a destination forged by others, with (I hoped) something beautiful on the other side. My decision to explore that path seems like a suitable place to go from my first post, as it took place during part of the transitional, unraveling time in my life.

In 2016 I embarked on a discernment process to explore a possible call to ordained ministry in the Episcopal church. As part of that process, I had to write a faith story, with set criteria, to explain how faith had shaped my life and what brought me to the exploration. I’m sharing it in part below, As it gives a good background for where I am now.

Faith Story – Written January, 2017

The small Church of Christ up the street from where I lived with my parents and two younger sisters was central to our life during my childhood. Faith was lived mainly though our membership and participation with that congregation. My early years were filled with Sunday school, potluck dinners, Vacation Bible School, and other gatherings inside that small-town church. I don’t recall giving much thought to the broader church outside those walls, but I remember that place as a family community I am blessed to have roots in.

We left the Church of Christ in my early teens for a non-denominational church in a nearby town. While my early years revolved around a church family, my teenage years were steeped in the culture wars. I was taught to work hard at being more spiritual, more pure, and a better witness in order to gain approval from the congregation and from God. The faith I learned was one of rules and dogma, not only for me to follow, but to worry about how well other people were following. I realize that perhaps this isn’t how faith was understood by others in that community, but this is how I grew to understand it.

In the years that followed my graduation from college and marriage, I became disillusioned with church and eventually stopped attending. I experienced a painful time of deep doubt and searching, trying to sort out my beliefs. I wondered if I would lose my faith altogether and what would be there to catch me if I did. I thought that church wasn’t the place for me and that I’d end up leaving it behind for good.

Instead, people and wisdom came into my life that helped me reimagine not only my faith, but also my ideas about church. I established a practice of centering prayer and reading the Daily Office each morning, began spending more time in nature, and found friendships and spiritual writing that opened my eyes to a variety of perspectives and possibilities. I now see this was a process of letting go of my ideas about God in order to be open to new practices and new understandings of who God is.

A book by Thomas Keating on liturgy by prompted me to find a liturgical church to visit, which led me to a local Episcopal church. My first Sunday there, the words we read from The Book of Common Prayer moved me with how they connected those of us present in that sanctuary with people all over the world and across time. In many ways I felt like I was both being welcomed home and shown an entirely different way of understanding church as the body of Christ.

Some faith transformations are exciting and dramatic. Mine happens to be one of moving through a rigid understanding of God, faith, and church into one that continues to amaze me with its “holy spaciousness,” to borrow a phrase from Gerald May. I understand now that my faith is a continually unfolding grace that opens my mind and heart to God and to others. I see that the Church is a community where we help each other remember that as the Body of Christ we are always in the process of death and rebirth, letting go and finding anew, and learning to live deeper in self-giving love.

In all these changes, I’ve experienced how spiritual practices and participation in the church open us more fully to the work of the Spirit in our lives. I grew up memorizing scripture, but when I began reading the Daily Office, practicing contemplative prayer, and spending time with other believers learning from its wisdom, the Bible became so much more than words and rules to me… Over and over, I’ve experienced what the Spirit can do when I open to new understandings of scripture and give myself over to its life-altering truth.

In a talk I heard by John O’ Donohue, he closed by telling the audience that he prayed his words would be seeds planted in their lives to provide shelter when they need it. This has been helpful to me as I’ve explored the possibility of pursuing seminary and ordination. I realize that in following such a path it may be difficult for others to understand what I’m doing, either because due to my gender it doesn’t align with their understanding of the Christian faith or because religious faith is not a part of their lives. So I’ve made it a prayer of my own that regardless of how others feel about me, my faith, or my vocation, my interactions with them would plant seeds that could grow to shelter them, whatever their own experience and regardless of their beliefs.

I’ve also wondered about applying this to a way of being for the church. We live in a world that is starving for things the church has to offer. Not just the physical day-to-day necessities that sustain life, but also things that have become scarce in most of our homes, workplaces, and public spaces: life-giving community, a sense of reverence for the mysteries of life and this world, experiences of stillness and silence, a place to be vulnerable, an appreciation for things that have no monetary value, and traditions that remind us of our connectedness and our mortality. I wonder about ways we can offer these as seeds to our entire communities – those in the church and those not – so they can turn to them for shelter.

All these experiences have brought me to this point. I realize now that I’ve been praying about vocation for even longer than I knew what it was. I’ve considered that perhaps all I am called to do is to live my faith with my family, parish, neighbors, and co-workers, without any additional formal training or change of career. I realize that is a possibility, yet I continue to feel drawn to seminary and the changes that path could open. The advice I have received from Jackie (my priest) is to keep taking each step, to stay open to whatever possibility may come from that, and then to prayerfully and willingly take the next step.

I admit there is a part of me that wonders what I am doing. Most of those I’ve spoken with who are connected with Episcopal dioceses make it clear that we don’t know what the Episcopal Church, let alone the priesthood, will look like in the next 10 to 30 years. There is doubt that sustaining a full-time parish priest will be an option for the majority of congregations. Considering this, I can’t help but think there is a chance that even if I complete seminary and become ordained, I may still end up working an eight-to-five desk job as I do now, leaving many (including me) wondering what it was all for. Yet I find that I am compelled to continue exploring the possibility of ordination, even with these uncertainties.

I’m trying keep in mind what Parker Palmer writes in his book on vocation, that “there is as much guidance in what does not and cannot happen in my life as there is in what can and does.” This journey of discerning vocation has been a beautiful and life-giving challenge, one that I will continue to walk whether or not ordination is the path for me. I’m grateful for all I’ve learned and pray to stay willing and open to wherever God leads from here.

2 thoughts on “That Time I Thought I’d Be a Priest

  1. I believe any theological study is never wasted. Had the chance to attend a Roman Catholic Lay School of Theology years ago and cherish the time learning from the monks and other students. Monks teach by their very way of being in the world, and it has helped light many a dark alley for me. Working for the PC(USA), many lay people appreciate pastors who work at other jobs, like they do. It’s a tough load to pull, but there are those ministers who enjoy it. Keep looking – so many ways to be a pastor everywhere you turn.


  2. Pingback: Willing | The Forest and the Trees

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s