[Image Description: black and white photo of a cloudy sky reflecting in a lake.]
People should not be excluded for things that are not their fault, especially kids who had nothing to do with adult actions and need their community. It’s wrong to shut them out.
I said these things, more or less, to the church elder in the church office after church.
I tried to say it meek and deferential like a Good Christian Girl, but below the surface I was fire, righteous rage, teenage defiance, and trembling with church-instilled fear.
I tried to be the Good Christian Girl for a very long time. I went away, returned, and tried on Good Christian Wife, Good Christian Mother, Good Christian Woman, too.
But I am a terrible actress with no poker face, and an insistence on a much more spacious God.
I wonder if he had any idea what I’d learn, that elder, that kind-hearted man turned instrument of patriarchy by church teachings, when he said to my face that it was not my place, but then changed his mind behind closed doors with other men.
I wonder if he knew I’d look back on that day and realize that any church that knows a teenage girl is right, but can’t say it to her face, is no place for her.
I was supposed to learn my place, but instead I became a cautionary tale in that kind of church, the wild woman in the wilderness of faith with scary ideas like there is enough for everyone and God is not a man, out here in an ever-widening circle of who’s included.
Ill-fitting facades, abandoned on shore, swimming naked in the waters, Spirit brooding over, waiting for what God will speak into existence next.
I wrestle with this God, translated into male words, interpreted as male.
Half of everyone excluded, while everyone pretends it had to be this way until everyone believes it’s always been this way.
Better to teach people to worship a god made in man’s image so men in charge can have their way.
Here I am, not a man so not like God, unable to find myself anywhere other than on the outside.
I lie awake on nights I can’t pretend I don’t care and think about not belonging.
A few nights ago I slipped out of bed and pulled back the curtains to see the winter night and full-moon light.
I stood there in my not-man body, cold air raising goosebumps on bare legs, and leaned my head against the window glass, looking up to see the Wolf Moon in a veil of clouds.
I always marvel at the moon, her waxing, waning, rhythmic revelation, dancing with oceans from afar.
That night, watching silvery reflections of a star blending light and shadow across a frosty landscape, I think moonlight knows the truest words for God.
For months now, I’ve felt ill at ease reading the morning office. I had a sense of why—mainly the overtly male language for God—but not clarity. So I continued, as I have for years, all the while noticing and honoring the discomfort. This week, clarity came in the form of questions: “Is there space for me here? Is there room for my becoming, when everything is father and he and him and lord?”
Meanwhile, I’d taken on the practice of praying hand-over-sternum, to remind me that the Divine is within, part of me.
This morning, while silently praying the confession and also practicing my reminder of the Divine within, the word “we” became “I” and “you” became “us” and suddenly I sense there may be space for me after all.
This is what I love about liturgy. It gives us a reservoir within which we can wrestle and flounder and question, all while being held and buoyed and never alone.
Here is how it sounded this morning:
Most merciful God, I confess that I have sinned against us in thought, word, and deed, by what I have done, and by what I have left undone. I have not loved us with my whole heart; I have not loved my neighbors as myself. I am truly sorry and I humbly repent. For the sake of our Son Jesus Christ, have mercy on me and forgive me; that I may delight in our will, and walk in our ways, to the glory of your Name. Amen.
We’re not absolved just because we’re not on the side of the ones we see as worst.
Lulled into the laziness of giving allegiance willy-nilly, based on label, assigning morality by default instead of seeing morality is not innate, invariable, indelible, in each person.
The rightness or wrongness of an action depends on many factors, but a wrong is not magically a right when committed by one of ours.
What may seem like a tree we want to stand in the shade of, tend, and nurture, could be a danger, bearing poison fruit.
And so.
It is on each of us to consider our alliances, to evaluate words and actions, to look around at those attracted to align with us as we follow.
If the fruit is often rotten, sometimes poison, spreading more harm than good, we ourselves will eventually succumb.
Better to withdraw allegiance, dancing alone in the wilderness if necessary, than stay planted, growing roots, in an orchard of poison fruit.
[Image description: water cascading over a short rock ledge into a pool of water, rocks along the banks of the stream, bare winter trees and cloudy sky in the background]
I see myself divided, dividing. Ruptured, unleashing a torrent, thoughts cascading one over another at images I abhor.
Flooded, current ever outward, all reaction, counteraction, oppositional, all or nothing, with or against, how could you, dueling calls for unity or division, backlash into the void.
Visceral, swirling chaos, overtaking.
Nearly carried away, then clarity. Take a long breath and dive deep.
Remember.
I can roll back the tide of my own chaos, the crashing wave after wave clamoring noise in every second.
I can stem the barrage of endless opinions from ego unchecked.
I can gather in the deluge of outward-flooding emotions into a reservoir of my own making.
I can calm them, sitting in stillness, allowing silence to flow in.
I can see where light and shadow within me co-mingle, hear each other out, acknowledge my own inconsistencies, what troubles me about my own beliefs, how far I am from the standards I apply to others.
And I can hold these contradictions gently until the clashing parts become letting go, letting go, letting go.
Myself distilled to deepest truths until all of it is loved, is love.
Finally, reservoir to the brim, flowing over creating tide pools of compassion, invitations for others to look deep and see that they, too, are love.
And in the depths it’s clear true unity begins within my own united heart.
[Image Description: evening sun shining from behind bare trees in winter, reflecting brilliantly from a small stream]
What is the truest, most beautiful truth you know for yourself right now?
Not the “truth,” external, imposed, from out there.
No.
I want to know the deep, quiet beauty that is so lovely it seems impossible, the truth that whispers in those quiet moments when there is no droning of pundits or parroters or pontificators.
The truth that glimmers, otherworldly, resplendent, abundant, beckoning from the realest part of you.
The one that is so warm, so healing, if it spilled over it could change the world.
When you glimpse it again and sit silent, remembering, let it tease the threads of your imagination long enough to coax it into knowing less ephemeral.
Let its golden radience permeate your awareness and then nurture it, returning to the silence, whenever it feels dim.
You need this now, your deepest truth, when external “truth” is pulled taut between two extremes and one is clamoring even more violently for your allegiance.
You need the touchstone of the beauty of your inner mooring to untangle the lies, to see clearly, to set us all free.
[Image description: winter meadow in the morning light]
I want to be a whole person.
I said this while sitting on my therapist’s couch one clear, autumn day. I couldn’t explain to her exactly what I meant, only this was the truest expression of my insides in words.
That was several years ago. I haven’t seen her in a long time.
What is my truest expression now?
I’m certain it still has to do with wholeness.
We are taught we can divide our way to wholeness.
Sheer off the undesirable parts of ourselves, the ones that cause discomfort with their messy, messy truth.
Divide ourselves from others who don’t look like us or think like us or fall in line like we were taught.
Divide, segregate, deny, shun.
And if we do, if we listen to the external, self-appointed authorities out there, we will possibly, one day, attain the ideal.
The ideal what?
The ideal cookie-cutter, uniform vision of success, spiritual or otherwise, as they define it.
Then we will be wholesome, acceptable, holy in their eyes.
All that’s required is to ignore that still, small, voice, deep within, whispering: wholeness can’t be found out there, can’t be defined by them.
You cannot divide your way to wholeness.
Turn and listen to that voice. Gather up the discarded petals you dutifully left trailing behind you as they watched.
Push through the double-dividing doors and run, hair-in-the-wind, into the meadow of your own knowing, arms wide-stretched, heart echoing:
[Image description: abstract photo with bright center]
Masculine. Feminine.
Words now defined as opposites, created prior to words as harmony among and within.
Interior balance of energy, each tantamount to the other, wholeness incarnate.
Diverse, yet coequal, until property, commodity, misogyny, took hold.
Multiple expressions of the feminine suppressed, confined, subdued, relegated to certain tasks and certain people.
God, divided.
We can call God Father, and he, and him, and Lord, and warrior, but not Mother, and she, and her, or even corresponding words that don’t exist because the default is always man.
I want the feminine side of God in all her forms.
Not to objectify God by claiming God a woman, the way women are objectified, claimed as God’s gift.
I want the wholeness, the fullness, the perfect entirety— without exclusion— of my own being. And God’s. And yours.
I want symmetry and reciprocity. The function and the beauty. The light and the shadow. The aspiration and the groundedness. The logic and the mystery. As it was. As it could be. If we didn’t split it all in two.